
General information based on the position at the date shown. Tax rules and HMRC guidance can change. Obtain advice tailored to your circumstances.
Paying customers or charities rather than paying a substantial fine might sound like a different kind of business expense. But does it produce a different tax result?
In a recent ScottishPower case, the Supreme Court’s answer was no.
What happened?
ScottishPower agreed payments of approximately £28 million to customers and charities to settle regulatory investigations. The settlements involved nominal fines of £1, alongside the substantial redress payments.
The company argued that the redress payments could be deducted when calculating its taxable trading profits. The Court of Appeal had agreed.
On 21 October 2026, the Supreme Court unanimously allowed HMRC’s appeal and restored the Upper Tribunal’s decision: none of the disputed redress payments was deductible. Supreme Court case summary.
Why the description was not enough
The Court examined the nature and purpose of the payments. They had been agreed to avoid substantial regulatory penalties and were sufficiently similar to penalties to fall outside expenditure incurred for the purposes of the trade under section 54(1)(a) of the Corporation Tax Act 2009.
Paying the money to customers or charities did not change that conclusion. Nor did treating the payments as expenses in the accounts. The Court also rejected separating out a customer payment from the overall settlement package. Judgment, paragraphs 88–99.
What should businesses take from this?
Our practical takeaway is to consider tax treatment before agreeing a regulatory settlement or forecasting its after-tax cost:
- Examine why each payment is being made, alongside the regulator’s findings and settlement terms.
- Avoid assuming that labels such as “redress”, “compensation” or “voluntary payment” establish deductibility.
- Review the settlement as a whole before assuming individual elements can receive different treatment.
Does this rule out every compensation payment?
No. This decision concerns particular regulatory payments made in place of substantial penalties. It should not be read as a blanket prohibition on deductions for ordinary commercial compensation. The Court expressly left the deductibility of legal fees for resisting disciplinary proceedings outside this appeal.
The lesson is to assess the underlying obligation and purpose, with advice tailored to the facts.
Case: ScottishPower (SCPL) Limited and others v Commissioners for His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs [2026] UKSC 35, Supreme Court, 21 October 2026.
General information based on the judgment checked on 4 November 2026. Individual payments and circumstances require separate analysis.
