
General information based on the position at the date shown. Tax rules and HMRC guidance can change. Obtain advice tailored to your circumstances.
A proposed business sale, property transfer or family succession plan can raise a deceptively simple question: “Does the tax advice we have received cover everything that matters?”
A specialist second opinion starts with understanding the facts and the decision you need to make. A clear briefing helps an adviser identify the important questions and agree a focused scope of work.
Here is our suggested preparation checklist for business owners and their accountants.
1. Explain what you want to achieve
Start with the commercial or family objective in plain English. Are you separating business activities, bringing in the next generation, preparing for a sale or reviewing an HMRC challenge?
Explain what must stay the same as well as what you want to change. For example, you may need to retain control, protect a continuing trade, preserve access to income or meet a buyer’s timetable.
“We want to transfer the property to the company” describes a proposed step. “We want simpler management and a workable succession plan” explains the objective. An adviser needs both.
2. Provide a simple ownership map
Set out who owns what now, including relevant companies, partnerships, trusts and personally held assets. Include ownership percentages, share classes and any important relationships between the parties.
For property matters, identify where each property is located and distinguish legal title from any separate beneficial ownership arrangements. Flag mortgages, guarantees and other restrictions that may affect the proposal.
A one-page diagram with supporting documents is usually easier to follow than a long email chain.
3. Share the existing advice and its assumptions
Provide the full written advice, calculations and proposed transaction steps, together with the information on which they were based.
Identify any assumptions about valuations, residence, business activities, ownership periods or future events. Explain what has changed since the advice was given.
A useful review tests the reasoning and its factual foundations. An isolated extract or a projected tax saving rarely tells the whole story.
4. Gather the documents that explain the position
The relevant material depends on the question. An initial document list might include:
- Recent accounts, relevant tax returns and supporting computations.
- Share registers, articles of association and shareholder agreements.
- Partnership or LLP agreements and relevant capital account information.
- Property purchase documents, valuations, leases and borrowing details.
- Draft sale, transfer or restructuring documents.
- Existing trust documents, where relevant to the review.
- HMRC correspondence, including the complete notice or decision and its date.
You do not need to assemble every document before making contact. Begin with a short outline, then agree which records are needed and how to share them securely.
5. Make the timetable clear
State whether the transaction is only being considered, documents are being negotiated or binding steps have already been taken.
List proposed completion dates and any deadlines shown in HMRC correspondence. Flag urgent dates at the outset so the adviser can assess whether the work can be completed in time.
6. Agree what the second opinion should deliver
Be clear whether you want a review of one technical point, a wider assessment of the proposed steps, a written opinion or support with implementation.
Useful questions include: which taxes are in scope, what further facts are needed, what uncertainty remains and who will take responsibility for the next steps?
The outcome may confirm the existing advice, identify a missing issue or show that a different approach needs consideration. It should help you make a better-informed decision.
Working with your accountant
BPS works alongside accountants and professional advisers on specialist tax matters. A second opinion can be provided behind the scenes or through a joint discussion with the client, according to the agreed engagement. Find out about our support for accountants.
Have a proposal you would like reviewed? Contact Bespoke Planning Solutions with a brief outline of your objective, the issue and your timetable.
