BESPOKE PLANNING SOLUTIONS LLP · TAX INSIGHTS

HMRC loses Osmond appeal: a tax saving is not the whole purpose test

Illustration accompanying HMRC loses Osmond appeal: a tax saving is not the whole purpose test

General information based on the position at the date shown. Tax rules and HMRC guidance can change. Obtain advice tailored to your circumstances.

For entrepreneurs planning share transactions, identifying the tax result is only part of the analysis. The reasons for the transaction also deserve careful attention.

What the Court of Appeal decided

In HMRC v Hugh Edward Mark Osmond & another [2026] EWCA Civ 1440, the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) dismissed HMRC’s appeal on 12 November 2026.

The share buybacks sought to secure Enterprise Investment Scheme disposal relief before a feared policy change. Obtaining an income tax advantage had been found not to be a main purpose.

The Court rejected HMRC’s argument that securing the CGT relief necessarily satisfied the transactions-in-securities income tax purpose test.

Purpose differed from effect. An actual income tax avoidance purpose can still be caught without a precisely calculated saving. Official judgment, paragraphs 35–57 and 76–78.

What should business owners take from it?

Our practical recommendation is to keep the proposed transaction, its objectives and its tax analysis together in one file.

Before proceeding with a buyback or restructuring, ask:

  • What is the intended commercial outcome?
  • Why are these particular steps proposed?
  • What alternatives were considered?
  • Which tax benefits are expected, and how do they influence the decision?
  • Do the supporting documents reflect what the decision-makers actually intend?

Those are questions for an honest assessment, not a template for manufacturing a favourable narrative after the event.

Clearance still requires complete disclosure

HMRC’s transactions-in-securities guidance says that tax considerations are material to a clearance application. A notification is void where the application and further information fail to disclose material facts and considerations fully and accurately.

Clearance also does not prevent a compliance check. HMRC explains the consequences where the facts differ from the disclosure or transactions extend beyond the notification’s scope.

For owners and referring accountants, the sensible response is to obtain a clear written analysis of the relevant provisions before documents are finalised.

A decision to apply carefully

The ruling concerns a specific statutory purpose test and established facts. It does not establish that a proposed transaction qualifies for EIS relief, capital treatment or any other relief.

If a transaction’s tax treatment is material to the decision, identify the assumptions and uncertainties before implementation.

Discuss a proposed transaction or specialist tax second opinion with BPS.

Back to all tax insights