
General information based on the position at the date shown. Tax rules and HMRC guidance can change. Obtain advice tailored to your circumstances.
An “agreed route with HMRC” sounds significant. But what does it actually deliver for LT4L clients?
Some professionals are reporting an agreement covering settlement and incorporation into the former corporate member. Clients need to understand what has been agreed, what remains unresolved and how the outcome compares with using a new company.
Historic liabilities do not disappear.
Incorporation does not retrospectively validate the original arrangements. Historic tax properly due remains payable, together with applicable interest and penalties.
CGT deferral and nil SDLT on incorporation are not unique to this proposed route and require careful consideration.
A qualifying section 162 incorporation into a new company can already defer CGT. Separately, the SDLT partnership rules can produce nil chargeable consideration where the circumstances support that result. Section 162 itself does not provide the SDLT treatment.
So what additional advantage does using the former corporate member provide?
HMRC’s own manual identifies a problem with the existing corporate member.
It expressly states: “Relief is not available where a partnership or LLP incorporates into an existing corporate member.” HMRC’s explanation is that the company already owns a share of the business assets. HMRC CG65700.
The proposed route involves withdrawing that company before incorporation. That is a material distinction, but the withdrawal itself needs scrutiny.
If the company gives up an interest in the underlying assets, it may realise a gain chargeable to corporation tax. If the remaining members’ relevant partnership shares increase, SDLT may also arise, subject to the applicable exclusions. A nil capital-account balance does not, by itself, establish that the company has no rights in the assets.
Section 162 relief on the later incorporation does not automatically shelter tax consequences arising on the earlier withdrawal.
A paragraph 12A election may help with historic SDLT, but a saving must be demonstrated.
Broadly it removes the relief from SDLT on assets transferring into a partnership but provides relief against SDLT charges on transactions within the partnership. By the same token, it may also have an impact on the reliefs available on exit. Once made, the election is irrevocable.
The benefit comes from changing which transactions are charged. It cannot be established simply by comparing historic and current property values. Clients need calculations showing the entry charge being accepted, the subsequent charges being removed and the total liability with and without the election.
Summary
An agreed process may offer valuable certainty. But clients should receive a costed comparison between settlement including making a 12a election followed by incorporation without a 12a election.
That comparison should include historic liabilities, any paragraph 12A saving or additional cost, taxes arising on withdrawal and incorporation.
The burning question remains, what exactly has HMRC accepted in writing, and is the client actually better off under this particular route?
